Author	[Modern View]
David Snipes 09-24-2012 11:02:08 198.239.210.178 Report to Moderator	How much power would it take to pull an AC 32' spring tooth cultivator, 3 rows of spring teeth and 4 rows of spring tines. I have 56 hp, is that enough? [Reply]   [No Email]
Dalet 09-27-2012 05:03:03 184.94.141.146 Report to Moderator	Re: Power to pull a 32' cultivator in reply to David Snipes, 09-24-2012 11:02:08   I have something similar to what the OP is possibly mentioning, its a Melroe Multiweeder. That unit doesn't take much power, but I would still have 100hp on it. I mainly use it for knocking down plowing in the spring and for working the ground before putting in wheat or oats. Due to the spring teeth if the ground is hard it will cheat and just scrape across the top of the ground and not do much good, but it can smooth out the ground quickly so we can spread fertilizer then work with the field cultivator. [Reply]  [No Email]
Doug Wi 09-25-2012 19:35:02 74.117.241.1 Report to Moderator	Re: Power to pull a 32' cultivator in reply to David Snipes, 09-24-2012 11:02:08   As other replies have suggested, we are dealing with different areas and different names for various machines. Most are assuming that you have a shank type field cultivator whitch takes power. i had a 24' wilrich behind my 3588 [150hp]. A good load for it. But from your desciption,I would say you have what I would call a spring tooth harrow. Excellent machine for getting a smooth seed bed. And pulls much easier than a field cultivator. Still way too much for 46hp , but not requiring the 150-200 hp as some suggested. But what the heck, hook on and give it a try when no one is watching. [Reply]  [No Email]
Brian in MA 09-26-2012 04:48:48 70.91.218.113 Report to Moderator	Re: Power to pull a 32' cultivator in reply to Doug Wi, 09-25-2012 19:35:02   Or wait until they are watching to pull it and prove them wrong (or not)! [Reply]  [No Email]
James22 09-25-2012 11:28:23 207.179.239.85 Report to Moderator	Re: Power to pull a 32' cultivator in reply to David Snipes, 09-24-2012 11:02:08   You might be able to "scratch" the ground if it is already tilled, otherwise not near enough power. As already stated, at least around 200 hp and more if wanting to go over 5 mph in untilled ground. [Reply]  [No Email]
David G 09-24-2012 20:18:41 205.215.206.18 Report to Moderator	Re: Power to pull a 32' cultivator in reply to David Snipes, 09-24-2012 11:02:08   I would want 200 HP. [Reply]  [No Email]
MF Poor 09-24-2012 13:39:27 75.88.169.147 Report to Moderator	Re: Power to pull a 32' cultivator in reply to David Snipes, 09-24-2012 11:02:08   Provided you don"t lower it into the ground, you"ll be OK. Neighbor with 210hp mfwd tractor has a 28"er that gives it a workout. My 140hp 2wd handles 20" but won"t exactly take off running with it. [Reply]  [No Email]
JMS./MN 09-24-2012 13:35:01 209.237.125.241 Report to Moderator	Re: Power to pull a 32' cultivator in reply to David Snipes, 09-24-2012 11:02:08   I pull a 24 foot Wilrich field cultivator with a 4450 MFWD, rated 145, cranks 190. Half of that AC would be too big for your tractor. [Reply]  [No Email]
ss55 09-24-2012 13:31:13 50.81.68.105 Report to Moderator	Re: Power to pull a 32' cultivator in reply to David Snipes, 09-24-2012 11:02:08   How deep and how fast do you want to pull it? [Reply]  [No Email]
DeltaRed 09-24-2012 12:34:16 67.6.219.50 Report to Moderator	Re: Power to pull a 32' cultivator in reply to David Snipes, 09-24-2012 11:02:08   Down the road,maybe.you were kidding,right?I seriously doubt that even my 1256 would handle that. [Reply]  [No Email]
David Snipes 09-24-2012 13:21:45 198.239.210.178 Report to Moderator	Re: Power to pull a 32' cultivator in reply to DeltaRed, 09-24-2012 12:34:16   I really didn't know, I just suspected it was too much, I've never pulled anything that big before. Now I feel like dummy, oh well, thanks for setting me right. [Reply]  [No Email]
paul 09-24-2012 20:17:17 66.44.133.112 Report to Moderator	Re: Power to pull a 32' cultivator in reply to David Snipes, 09-24-2012 13:21:45   Only bad questions are the unasked one's, you did good asking., no dummy. :) Keep asking questions, despite our rather overwhelming chorus here, we can be nice at times too. :) --->Paul [Reply]  [No Email]
Brian in MA 09-24-2012 17:39:28 71.89.8.22 Report to Moderator	Re: Power to pull a 32' cultivator in reply to David Snipes, 09-24-2012 13:21:45   I'm kind of with you, I have never seen what is called a field cultivator work, they don't seem to exist around here. We always used a spring tooth harrow for smoothing in the field before seeding when I was a kid, and that thing was about 20' wide and Gramp pulled it with his 641 Ford, so if that was 32' wide I could see a 56 horse tractor handling it no problem. Don't feel bad about asking a question, there are a lot of people here with knowledge that I will never have. You can't get information without asking questions. [Reply]  [No Email]
paul 09-25-2012 10:42:05 76.77.196.231 Report to Moderator	Re: Power to pull a 32' cultivator in reply to Brian in MA, 09-24-2012 17:39:28   A field cultivator 'here' works about as hard as a disk, and does the same job. In our clay, a disk is a bad thing, it packs the wet ground like a sheepsfoot packer, we all parked our disks in the 1970's and got field cultivators. They have meduim strength shanks, either spring loaded or S shaped springy type, with duck foot cultivator shovels of 5-9 inches on them (can have narrow 2 inch spike shovels, but rare). A harrow is a light drag, some are wire spring type like jumbo siderake teeth, some are spike like the typical old horse drag/harrow. (Most field cultivators and some disks 'here' have a couple rows of 'harrow' teeth on the rear of them to level off the ground nicely.) A chisel plow has very strong shanks that go into the ground as deep as a plow, and pull as hard as one, some are 2 inch wide bottoms, some are 3 or 4 inch twisted shovels. (Some chisel plows have a row or 2 of field cultivator shanks on the rear to level off the rough ground.) I've seen imlements that are confusing between these 3, and hard for me to put in one or another classification as they seem to cross over. In any case, the 20 foot harrow I have is a good match for a 45 hp tractor, the 25 foot one I have it often too big a load for a 45 hp tractor, so it would be hard, in my soils, to pull anything 32 feet wide with 60 hp, even a light harrow. But it depends on soils, conditions, and what the implement actually is, and if it has a few harrow rows on the back of it. In spring I can't hadly pull the 20 foot disk (the few times I use a disk any more) in fresh dirt. But in fall if I want to disk down some cornstalks in the firm dirt, the smaller tractor hardly knows the disk is back there. Then the neighbors have come with a new type of disk, they have 400 hp pulling their 24 foot disk - it's a massive, huge bladed thing that works the soil deeper than a plow. It's so hard to judge an implement with just a name to it, never sure exactly what it is we are talking about. So this was a good thread, good question. Maybe the answers weren't so good. :) --->Paul [Reply]  [No Email]
DeltaRed 09-24-2012 17:14:53 67.6.219.50 Report to Moderator	Re: Power to pull a 32' cultivator in reply to David Snipes, 09-24-2012 13:21:45   Thats OK,we all ask a stupid once in a while....Thats how we learn. :) Steve [Reply]  [No Email]
thurlow 09-24-2012 12:21:12 74.177.51.22 Report to Moderator	Re: Power to pull a 32' cultivator in reply to David Snipes, 09-24-2012 11:02:08   paul's got it; bought a 25 or 26 ft Glencoe, back in the dark ages........intending to pull it with a 4620 or 1066 (both 135 pto hp); neither would pull it the way it needed to be pulled 'til I removed a few shanks. When I got a 180 hp tractor, I was able to put the shanks back on........ [Reply]  [No Email]
paul 09-24-2012 11:17:16 76.77.196.231 Report to Moderator	Re: Power to pull a 32' cultivator in reply to David Snipes, 09-24-2012 11:02:08   Assuming you are serious, a 32 foot field cultivator would take about 200 hp 'here'. You might be able to pull it if you don't put it in the dirt? I pulled a 16 foot field cultivator with 85 hp, as the tractor got old that got to be a lot. I pulled a 22 and now 24 foot field cultivator with 145hp, and that's about all it wants for traction esp with duals. Sometimes field cultivators, harrows, and chisel plows are called differently in different regions of the country, so if I'm miss-speaking on your implement then never mind? --->Paul [Reply]  [No Email]
David Snipes 09-24-2012 11:25:47 198.239.210.178 Report to Moderator	Re: Power to pull a 32' cultivator in reply to paul, 09-24-2012 11:17:16   Thanks, I suspected it might be way too big. [Reply]  [No Email]